The Hernia That Should Never Have Become an Emergency

A hernia is one of those problems people are very good at ignoring.
“It doesn’t hurt.” “I can push it back.” “I’ll get it operated later.” "I’ve had it for years.”
But sometimes, “later” becomes an emergency.

Recently, we treated a patient who had lived with a groin hernia for a long time. Instead of getting definitive surgical treatment, he visited several village practitioners and people posing as doctors. At one point, someone even attempted to aspirate the swelling.

Eventually, he arrived at our hospital in shock with a strangulated hernia. What could have been a planned, relatively straightforward hernia repair had transformed into a major emergency operation.
A large open surgery was required. Because of the condition of the bowel and the operative field, mesh placement was not appropriate.

The patient survived—but his surgery was bigger, his recovery was considerably longer, and the physical and emotional burden was far greater.

And that is what makes this story so frustrating. The hernia itself was not unusual. The delay was.

From Ancient Remedies to Modern Hernia Surgery

The history of hernia surgery is surprisingly old. Descriptions of hernias can be traced back to ancient Egyptian medical writings, including the Ebers Papyrus, dating to around 1555 BC. Hippocrates also described hernias, and later anatomical understanding developed through the work of Galen and others.
For centuries, however, hernia treatment was crude.
There were attempts at manipulation, trusses, cauterisation and various forms of surgical intervention.
The fundamental problem was simple:
Surgeons could see the bulge, but they didn't yet fully understand the anatomy or biomechanics of the abdominal wall.

The breakthrough came in the late nineteenth century.

Bassini Changed Hernia Surgery

In the late 1800s, Edoardo Bassini developed a systematic operation for inguinal hernia. Instead of simply dealing with the protruding sac, he reconstructed the posterior wall of the inguinal canal and narrowed the internal ring. It was a major conceptual advance. Bassini's principles influenced generations of hernia surgeons and became the foundation from which many later repairs evolved.

Then came other tissue repairs.

Shouldice.

McVay.

Nyhus.

Each attempted to improve anatomical reconstruction and reduce recurrence but there was a fundamental problem with many tissue repairs:

You were trying to repair a hole by pulling tissues together under tension and tension is not a friend of a durable hernia repair.

Then Came the Mesh Revolution

The idea of reinforcing the abdominal wall with prosthetic material gradually transformed hernia surgery. In the twentieth century, surgeons began experimenting with synthetic materials. Then came the concept that would change elective inguinal hernia surgery forever:

tension-free mesh repair.

The Lichtenstein repair became one of the most established open mesh techniques. Instead of forcing weakened tissues together, a mesh is positioned to reinforce the area.
Modern international guidelines recommend mesh-based repair as the first choice for most adult groin hernias, either through an open approach or a laparo-endoscopic approach.

Then Surgeons Started Looking From the Other Side

The next revolution was laparoscopy.
Instead of approaching the hernia from the front through a traditional groin incision, surgeons began working in the preperitoneal plane from behind. Two techniques became particularly important:

TAPP — Transabdominal Preperitoneal Repair

The surgeon enters the abdominal cavity laparoscopically, opens the peritoneum, places the mesh in the preperitoneal space and then closes the peritoneum over it.

TEP — Totally Extraperitoneal Repair

The surgeon reaches the preperitoneal space without entering the abdominal cavity. Both techniques place the mesh behind the defect, reinforcing the entire myopectineal orifice.
The current HerniaSurge recommendations consider TAPP and TEP comparable options, with the choice depending largely on the surgeon's training and expertise. Laparo-endoscopic repair is associated with faster recovery and lower risk of chronic pain in appropriate patients.

For appropriately selected patients, laparoscopic repair can offer smaller incisions, less postoperative discomfort and faster return to normal activities and this is where the story of our patient becomes particularly important.
He might have had a planned laparoscopic TEP or TAPP. Or an elective open mesh repair.

Instead, he required emergency surgery.

What Happens When a Hernia Strangulates?

A reducible hernia can often be pushed back into the abdomen but sometimes the hernia becomes trapped.
This is called incarceration.
If the blood supply to the trapped bowel becomes compromised, it becomes strangulated. Now the situation is completely different.
The bowel can become ischemic. It can become gangrenous. It can perforate.
The patient can develop severe infection, sepsis and shock.

The surgeon is no longer simply repairing a hole in the abdominal wall. The surgeon may have to remove dead bowel, deal with contamination and fight to stabilise a critically ill patient and in a contaminated or high-risk operative field, placing mesh may not be appropriate.

That means the surgeon sometimes has to perform a much larger operation without the advantages of a routine elective mesh repair.

A Hernia Is Not an Abscess

One of the most concerning details in our patient's history was that someone had attempted to aspirate the groin swelling. A hernia is not a fluid collection. It is not something that should be punctured because it “looks like a swelling.” A groin lump can have many causes. A proper examination—and sometimes ultrasound or other imaging—is needed to establish the diagnosis.

When the diagnosis is uncertain, don't let someone treat the swelling blindly.

The Most Important Hernia Treatment May Be Timing

Today, surgeons have remarkably sophisticated options for treating groin hernias. Open mesh repair. Laparoscopic TEP. Laparoscopic TAPP and other techniques tailored to individual patients but all these options work best when the patient arrives before the situation becomes a crisis.

Elective surgery allows us to:

• Properly evaluate the patient

• Optimise medical conditions

• Select the appropriate technique

• Choose the right mesh

• Operate in a controlled environment

• Plan recovery

Emergency strangulation takes many of those choices away.

That is why I keep thinking about this patient. The difficult part wasn't that we didn't know how to operate. The difficult part was that the patient reached us after the window for a simple operation had closed.

Don't Wait for Your Hernia to Become an Emergency

If you have a groin swelling that appears when you stand, cough or strain… If it disappears when you lie down… If you have a dragging sensation or discomfort… get it examined. And if a previously reducible hernia suddenly becomes painful, hard, swollen or impossible to push back—especially with vomiting, abdominal distension or weakness—treat it as an emergency.
Don't wait for a home remedy. Don't allow someone to puncture it. Don't keep postponing it.

A hernia that can be repaired electively is very different from a hernia that arrives strangulated.

The goal of modern surgery isn't merely to save patients from emergencies. It is to prevent those emergencies from happening in the first place.

Have a groin swelling or suspected hernia?

Get it evaluated by a qualified surgeon.

Surgery Central — Modern Hernia Surgery | Ethical, Evidence-Based Surgical Care

📞 Call us to book a consultation.